SeaWorld sued over 'enslaved' killer whales

From the BBC

7 February 2012

Deadly orca back in Florida show Five killer whales have been named as plaintiffs in a lawsuit which argues they deserve the same constitutional protection from slavery as humans. A US judge is considering a complant by People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals' (Peta) against SeaWorld. It is reportedly the first time a US court has heard legal arguments over whether animals should enjoy the same constitutional protections as humans. SeaWorld's legal team said the case was a waste of time and resources. The marine park's lawyer, Theodore Shaw, told the court in San Diego: "Neither orcas nor any other animal were included in the 'We the people'... when the Constitution was adopted." He said that if the case were successful, it could have implications not just on how other marine parks or zoos operate, but even on the police use of sniffer dogs to detect bombs and drugs.

Peta says the killer whales are treated like slaves for being forced to live in tanks and perform daily at the SeaWorld parks in California and Florida. It is not considered likely that the whales will win their freedom, but campaigners said they were pleased the case even made it to a courtroom. The lawsuit invokes the 13th Amendment to the constitution, which abolished "slavery or involuntary servitude" in the US. Jeffrey Kerr, the lawyer representing the five whales, said: "For the first time in our nation's history, a federal court heard arguments as to whether living, breathing, feeling beings have rights and can be enslaved simply because they happen to not have been born human. By any definition these orcas have been enslaved here." Hearing the arguments for about an hour, US District Judge Jeffrey Miller raised concerns over whether animals could be represented as plaintiffs in a lawsuit. He will issue a ruling at a later date.

Peta names the five wild-captured orca plaintiffs as Tilikum and Katina, at SeaWorld Orlando; and Kasatka, Corky, and Ulises, at SeaWorld San Diego. It is not Tilikum's first time in the media spotlight - he drowned his trainer before horrified spectators in February 2010, prompting a ban on the Florida park's employees entering the water to perform tricks with the orcas. The same whale has also been linked to two other deaths.

[Of course if you’ve been following this story you’ll know that the case failed. It’s still an interesting proposition though – Are Orca’s people? Personally I wouldn’t have chosen them as the creatures to use to gain rights for non-humans. I’d picked some of the great apes such as Orang-utan’s or Gorilla’s. Orca’s are, I think, too alien to be easily classified as people even if they are self aware and as intelligent as they seem. I wouldn’t be too surprised if such a ruling is made somewhere at some point – especially if (actually when if I think about it for a second) we start to manipulate other creatures genomes to enhance their cognitive functioning. As they say: Watch this space!]