About Me

My photo
I have a burning need to know stuff and I love asking awkward questions.

Wednesday, March 21, 2007

Atheists' bleak alternative

by Jeff Jacoby for the Boston Globe

December 13, 2006

From the land that produced "A Christmas Carol" and Handel's "Messiah," more evidence that Christianity is fading in Western Europe: Nearly 99 percent of Christmas cards sold in Great Britain contain no religious message or imagery. "Traditional pictures such as angels blowing trumpets over a stable, Jesus in his manger, the shepherds and three wise men following the star to Bethlehem are dying out," the Daily Mail reports. A review of some 5,500 Christmas cards turns up fewer than 70 that make any reference to the birth of Jesus. "Hundreds . . . avoided any image linked to Christmas at all" -- even those with no spiritual significance, such as Christmas trees or Santa Claus.

Presumably the greeting-card industry is only supplying what the market demands; if Christian belief and practice weren't vanishing from the British scene, Christian-themed cards wouldn't be, either. But some Britons, not all of them devout, are resisting the tide. Writing in the Telegraph, editor-at-large Jeff Randall -- who describes himself as "somewhere between an agnostic and a mild believer" -- announces that any Christmas card he receives that doesn't at least mention the word "Christmas" goes straight into the trash. "Jettisoning Christmas-less cards is my tiny, almost certainly futile, gesture against the dark forces of political correctness," he writes. "It's a swipe at those who would prefer to abolish Christmas altogether, in case it offends 'minorities.' Someone should tell them that, with only one in 15 Britons going to church on Sundays, Christians are a minority."

Meanwhile, the employment law firm Peninsula says that 75 percent of British companies have banned Christmas decorations for fear of being sued by someone who finds the holiday offensive. And it isn't only in December that this anti-Christian animus rears its head. British Airways triggered a furor when it ordered an employee to hide the tiny cross she wears around her neck. At the BBC, senior executives agreed that they would not air a program showing a Koran being thrown in the garbage -- but that the trashing of a Bible would be acceptable. "It's extraordinary," remarks Randall. "In an increasingly godless age, there is a rising tide of hatred against those who adhere to biblical values." A "tyrannical minority" of intolerant secularists is openly contemptuous of traditional moral norms. "The teachings and guidance of old-fashioned Christianity offend them, so they seek to remove all traces of it from public life."

You don't have to be especially pious to find this atheist zealotry alarming. Nor do you have to live in Europe. Though religion remains important in American life, antireligious passion is surging here, too. Examples abound: In two recent best sellers , Sam Harris heaps scorn on religious believers, whose faith he derides as "a few products of ancient ignorance and derangement." A study in the Journal of Religion and Society claims that belief in God correlates with higher rates of homicide, sexual promiscuity, and other social ills, and that when compared with relatively secular democracies, the churchgoing United States "is almost always the most dysfunctional." Secular absolutists demand that schools and government venues be cleansed of any hint of religious expression -- be it a cross on the Los Angeles County seal, a courthouse display of the Ten Commandments, or the words "under God" in the Pledge of Allegiance.

What is at stake in all this isn't just angels on Christmas cards. What society loses when it discards Judeo-Christian faith and belief in God is something far more difficult to replace: the value system most likely to promote ethical behavior and sustain a decent society. That is because without God, the difference between good and evil becomes purely subjective. What makes murder inherently wrong is not that it feels wrong, but that a transcendent Creator to whom we are answerable commands: "Thou shalt not murder." What makes kindness to others inherently right is not that human reason says so, but that God does: "Love thy neighbor as thyself; I am the Lord."

Obviously this doesn't mean that religious people are always good, or that religion itself cannot lead to cruelty. Nor does it mean that atheists cannot be beautiful, ethical human beings. Belief in God alone does not guarantee goodness. But belief tethered to clear ethical values -- Judeo-Christian monotheism -- is society's best bet for restraining our worst moral impulses and encouraging our best ones. The atheist alternative is a world in which right and wrong are ultimately matters of opinion, and in which we are finally accountable to no one but ourselves. That is anything but a tiding of comfort and joy.

[Whilst interesting to see the decline in religious based Christmas cards as yet another indicator of the decline of Christianity in the UK I do rather question this ‘War on Christmas’ fear being whipped up on both sides of the ‘Pond’. I think that’s its nothing more than rank nonsense as is the idea that only Judeo-Christian ethics can ‘save us’ from ourselves. A secular atheist world view is far from bleak. If it was, why is Europe in particular apparently turning its back on Christianity in ever increasing numbers? If the Church was fulfilling an obvious need then why have congregations been falling since the 1950’s? To say that Christianity in particular is the cure for what ails us calls into question why the cure has failed during the last 2000 years - Maybe because it isn’t a cure for anything after all?]

6 comments:

Sadie Lou said...

eh...it doesn't mean anything. The slow sales of religious-themed cards just means that consumerism is the main reason for the season. Nothing more...

Juggling Mother said...

I've seen the 75% of businesses have banned decorations figure andies about before, but All the comapanies I have worked for ver the past 5 years (that'll be, umm, 6 companies, big and small, public & private) had xmas decorations. So do ALL retailers. All leisure facilities I can think off (resturants, cinema's, theatres, sports centres, etc), and all public service offices/officers I have spoken to, so as that covers way more than 25% of employers, I'm confused.

of course, many of those employers have banned a specific type of decoration - a lot have banned fairly lights for example - but that is for H&S reasons (and yes, I have heard of people being injured and even killed by fairy lights!). I think the daily mail may be whipping up a non-existent storm.

No surprise there then:-)

Oh, and on the Xmas cards - i don't do that so wouldn't know, but generally the "christian" ones are sooooo dull! Who wouldn't want a brightly coloured dancing penguin intead of a bland and unchanged for 200 years piccy of some cows sniffing a manger full of hay (and baby)?

CyberKitten said...

Sadie said: The slow sales of religious-themed cards just means that consumerism is the main reason for the season. Nothing more...

Maybe. Christmas has certainly become more commercial year on year... But why aren't Christians sending religious Christmas cards? They're certainly available. Our office had a few sent to it by a well known Christian boss in our department. Is it that Christians are sending less religious cards or that there are less Christians to send them?

I agree with JM about the decorations. They are everywhere during the Christmas season as are the endless carols.... I've alo never been in an office that didn't have at least some decoration.... although we have been officially told not to hang them from the lights and not to stand on chairs to put them up... [grin].

There is not, nor has there ever been, a 'war' on Christmas.

Sadie Lou said...

Christians are consumers too. I think we lose focus during Christmas as well.

CyberKitten said...

But isn't Christmas a *particularly* good time to spread the message? I would've though that religious Christmas cards were... well, an obvious choice for the Christian card sender.....

Skywolf said...

Hmm. I'm kind of on the fence here, because on the one hand I get irritated by Christians constantly proclaiming, around Christmas and Easter, that 'Jesus is the reason for the season' ('Christmas' and Easter - which they haven't even bothered to change the name of - are both Pagan festivals which were usurped by Christians, and some of us still choose to celebrate the more pagan aspects of those festivals, which have nothing whatsoever to do with Jesus), yet on the other hand I do get annoyed with ridiculous political correctness that tries to stifle one sector of belief whilst ignoring another. Hindus celebrate Diwali, Muslims celebrate Ramadan, Jews celebrate Hanukkah, and Christians celebrate Christmas. I think all of these represent the amazing diversity of our world, and should all be held in esteem, regardless of a person's individual beliefs. And to suggest that the celebration of one offends followers of another is utterly ridiculous. The only people who ever claim such nonsense are politically correct social worker types. I have never heard of any non-Christian religious group claiming to find Christmas celebrations offensive. Give me a break.