About Me

My photo
I have a burning need to know stuff and I love asking awkward questions.

Thursday, November 20, 2014


Just Finished Reading: 1848 – Year of Revolution by Mike Rapport (FP: 2008)

Until I embarked on my recent foray into European history I had heard about much of it, at least in passing, but knew little of the detail. Until very recently this was the state of things regarding the continent wide series of revolts that shock Europe in the year 1848. I knew they had happened but I had no idea what caused them, what actually happened or what the consequences where. Well, I am most definitely no longer ignorant on these counts. My only regret in reading this substantial looking (at just over 400 pages) volume is that I took so long to read it. I have to say that it left me stunned with its breadth, detail, explanatory power and majestic quality. More than once I almost read this open mouthed with amazement, both at the events described and the brilliance of those descriptions. It is not often that you can call a book of European political history gripping but this is certainly one example.

Anyway, as to the story itself. Ever since the defeat of Napoleon in 1815 the continent had only seemed to be at peace. From time to time revolts and insurrections broke out and where, on the whole, brutally repressed. But something, it seemed was building in the background. 30 years later the powder keg, so carefully constructed by political and economic forces by and large ignored by the powerful and wealthy ignited first in Paris (where else!) and then, as news arrived in other parts, across the Habsburg Empire. At first the response was typical of all authoritarian regimes – send in the army. But cut-backs and lack of political will failed to quell things as quickly as expected and, as to surprise to the revolutionaries themselves, the great and the good paused and began to worry. For a moment the Empire itself stumbled and looked, at least for a while, as if it would fall into chaos. The revolutionaries took heart and the revolt spread, from country to country, province to province. Political careers and political parties emerged from nowhere and became movements and ideologies – Socialism and Communism amongst them.

Two countries, or actually aspiring countries, saw their chance and to a greater or lesser degree pushed for unification. Both Italy and Germany began their long and rocky journey towards the states they are today. Both journeys where incredibly complex and I thought where defining moments in the book as I grappled with the forces that gave birth to both countries decades later. Fortunately the author really knew his stuff and guiding my sometimes aching brain through the labyrinthine pathways and innumerable names (a few of which I recognised from somewhere) of those involved in revolution, counter revolution and oppression. I fully intend to follow up these individual stories in even more detail later.

After the initial shock of the continental revolt wore off and the inevitable infighting between the revolutionary and reforming parties started (which I read with great sadness and much shaking of head) the forces of reaction fought back. When initial victories went their way they redoubled their efforts and managed to splinter many of the forces ranged against them – being made up, as they were, of both military and political novices. Within the year the inevitable sad reality hit home. The revolutions, started with such verve and such hope, had failed. Not completely and not to the same extent everywhere but the highest hopes and the strongest demands had not been met. After the great initial earthquake the aftershocks hardly disturbed the ruling elite’s sleep – until 1914 that is when the chickens released in 1848 came very much back to roost.

If things had gone differently in 1848 and Serbia in particular had managed to gain independence, or even some sort of acceptable autonomy, would have a revolutionary band have planned the assassination of the Arch duke? If 1848 had been a success in revolutionary terms would the world have collapsed into conflict in 1914 finally destroying the Habsburg Empire that still stood, weakened but functioning, after the revolts had been so brutally supressed? Did the events of 1848 define the world in the 20th century? These are indeed interesting questions and if you want to move towards answering them then I heartily recommend you read this fascinating, gripping and superbly constructed work of political history.

4 comments:

Stephen said...

If ever I visit Germany, I want to go to Stpaulskirche in Frankfurt, where Germany hovered on the verge of becoming a democratic republic. Alas for Germany and for Europe, it took another century before that dream was fixed and realized.

CyberKitten said...

They did have a few near misses that might have prevented the huge lurch to the right which plunged the world into years of destructive war. I have a substantial book on the history of Prussia coming up which, I hope, will explain more.

VV said...

Did you review another book that covered the unification of Italy and Germany, or did you mention this book when you picked it up, saying you would review it later? This seems familiar. I know nothing about the unification of Italy, but I would like to learn about it. I know a good bit about German unification, but need to learn more. I teach about the unification of Germany and I've yet to find any text that is accessible for college students. The texts written for that audience tend to be too dry and cerebral for most students to get into. I'll put this on my Kindle list. I'll see if I can make time to read it over Winter break while also working on an attic remodel.

CyberKitten said...

V V said: Did you review another book that covered the unification of Italy and Germany, or did you mention this book when you picked it up, saying you would review it later? This seems familiar.

I probably mentioned this earlier as a 'coming soon' thing.

V V said: I teach about the unification of Germany and I've yet to find any text that is accessible for college students. The texts written for that audience tend to be too dry and cerebral for most students to get into.

There's definitely very little that's dry about this book. OK, it's complicated and detailed but the explanations are excellent. It is told chronologically so it hops from area to area as the year proceeds but you could probably skim read over the non-German or non-Italian bits if required.

If they're 16-18 year olds with an interest in history they might find this tough going in places (I know I did) but I think they'll find it very rewarding. I learnt a lot from this book and its certainly prompted me to want to know more about the period and the follow on results of these incidents. There will be (of course) much more European history to come here: Next up being the Liberation of Paris in 1944.