About Me

My photo
I have a burning need to know stuff and I love asking awkward questions.

Thursday, August 24, 2023


Just Finished Reading: A Mind of its Own – How Your Brain Distorts and Deceives by Cordelia Fine (FP: 2005) [211pp] 

Do you think your brain has ever lied to you? Well, the short answer is: Yes. I’m not talking about optical illusions or anything like that. I’m talking about the real-time modification of everyday reality – minute by minute, second by second. Again, I don’t mean that your reality is being modified by outsiders, by the media or big business – no, you’re being manipulated from the inside, by your own brain.  

How do we know this? Essentially from hundreds of experiments undertaken over decades of research into how our brains operate and how they manipulate reality to make you feel good, to get you to do things and to get you through the day in (mostly) one piece. The brain can edit your memories to show you in the best light after you’ve messed up or had been caught doing something you shouldn’t - even something as simple as breaking your diet. The brain can blame others for your faults and see responsibility for other’s failures while waving away your own responsibility without a second thought. It will tell you that you can indeed drive that fast safely and that you are indeed above average (along with 85% of those surveyed) in a whole host of skills and abilities. Your odds of getting ill, according to your grey matter, is much lower than average as is the speed of recovery if you do, indeed, fall prey to a nasty bug. You will, naturally, live longer than average and may indeed live long enough that science catches up and makes you immortal. There is, of course, practically nothing to worry about and whatever goes wrong just isn’t you fault and never could be.  

I could go on, but I won’t. I picked this up last year along with another of the authors books in my favourite Indie bookshop. Overall, it was a fun read if a little repetitive looking at study after study and experiment after experiment showing that our brain just can’t be trusted to tell us the hard cold truth about ourselves or the world around us. What made it more that readable for me was the authors style which was very down to earth and often very funny. I did laugh out loud more than once at her observations regarding the hoops our brains jumped through to accommodate their version of reality. I think the biggest thing I took away from this slim volume is that when your brain/mind tells you something that seems ‘obvious’ about what’s going on around you – just pause for a second and think about what potential BS your brain is feeding you. Was what just happened REALLY out of your control or is that just a cover for you not paying attention or not thinking things through before you opened your mouth or pressed that button. Is that person ahead of you REALLY a deadbeat or is that just your deep-seated prejudice talking (or your parents' prejudice echoing inside your head). It’s time to pause and reflect. 

Of course, the only problem with a lot of Psychology and Social Psychology experiments is the fact that the tests are run on university students by and large in the USA or Europe. So, we have a small, self-selecting group that is supposedly telling us things about the WHOLE of humanity. Generally, these people are going to be above average intelligence (or they probably wouldn’t have made the grade to get into Uni) and more likely to be Middle Class or at least relatively wealthy. I’m also guessing that most of the experimental volunteers are male and white – and the results of these experiments are extrapolated to cover ALL of humanity is all of its diversity. So, pinch of salt required... But, saying that, this is an interesting read that will get you wondering exactly why you do, want to do, or think/believe in the things you do. I think we all know people who blame others for everything bad that happens to them but who absolve themselves of any responsibility for their own failings – now I know exactly why such things happen. Recommended and more to come from this author. 

[Labels Added: 0, Labels Total: 66] 

4 comments:

Stephen said...

In Britain universities may be limited to students who are academic performers, but that's not the case in the United States, which is why we have remedial English and math classes for 20 year olds whose brains haven't developed much past sixth grade, AFAIK.

Sounds like an incredibly interesting book -- the basic idea is familiar, but reminders are always good. I'm always taken aback to read journals written after an event happened and then to compare them against my 'memory'. Lots of plot holes are created!

CyberKitten said...

Even with the increase in places available the competition to get into Uni is intense so the entry grades - especially into the best Universities - keep going up. For mixed reasons it took me 3 attempts....

It is an interesting book if a little 'dated' by now. Certainly one full of ideas and food for further thought.

Memory is an *odd* beast. Even something as mundane as "remembered" quotes from movies can be surprisingly different from the actual spoken quote. A few times I've honestly wondered if 'The Matrix' had changed something after being CONVINCED my memory was correct only to find out it wasn't - and sometimes it wasn't even close!!

VV said...

What if your brain regularly tells you the opposite? That the problem isn’t the shitty way you’ve been mistreated, that somehow it’s your fault? That you don’t really have friends, they’re just being polite and if they knew what a horrible person you are, or how dumb you really are, they wouldn’t have anything to do with you? Stuff like that. I wonder about broken brains? When, where, and why did the programming, or lying go astray? Is there a way to flip the switch for people whose brains regularly beat them up? Just thinking.

CyberKitten said...

Oh, I know a few people like that. They've won accolades, awards & prizes for their work over many years, and still think that they're fake and they'll be found out at any moment - and that the people giving them praise are either stupid or lying....

The human brain is the most complex thing we're aware of - so its not great surprise that it gets messed up sometimes. I think its more surprising that it functions so well so often! The 'faults' are probably caused by faulty genes, problems in the womb (mother smoking, drinking, taking drugs or just her own particular genetic issues), and then early environmental issues including bad/toxic parenting.

The brain is *very* plastic so can 'learn' its a piece of shit early on and that kind of childhood programming is *very* difficult to reverse - though not impossible. If I encounter a particularly fucked up person my first thought (until proven otherwise) is to blame the parents........