Just Finished Reading: Future Home of the Living God by Louise Erdrich (FP: 2017) [337pp]
The News was not good. Scientists around the world struggled to understand exactly what was going on and they were failing. From what they could discern, for unknown reasons, the process of Evolution had stopped and was, indeed, at least in some cases going into reverse. Plants and animals where no longer breeding ‘true’ and the resulting offspring was increasingly populating the world. What was worse, at least from a human perspective, was the fact that food crops were failing across the planet. The world was teetering on the edge of famine and chaos. All of this was background noise to Cedar Hawk Songmaker who had much bigger fish to fry. She was four months pregnant and had just been given the contact details of her birth mother on the Ojibwe reservation. Wanting to know her real roots before the baby is born Cedar is determined to travel to see her mother and finally know why she was given up for adoption. Meanwhile the country is falling apart and a pregnant woman, especially if they are carrying a normal baby, is a very valuable asset indeed to anyone who can hold her.
To be honest I picked this up almost exclusively because of the title. Reading the blurb regarding a collapse of society, weird biological happenings and a strong Native American theme made me take it home... where it rested in a pile of books for EIGHT years.... [lol]
Anyway, it’s read now... My overall reaction is quite mixed. The writing is actually very good if a little slow in places. This is the author’s 16th book so she should be pretty good by this stage! Characterisation throughout is very good and the main character is totally believable in her actions and motivations. Her personal philosophy is quite messed up – just like normal people – with a mixture of half understood Native American reading, Catholicism and her adoptive parents Western-styled Buddhism. Other characters – especially both of her families (full of other messy/realistic complications) are also very well drawn and interesting. The societal/political collapse is, as is usually the case, a little overblown but at least the adaptation to the new conditions takes months rather than moments which makes it somewhat more believable. The inevitable ‘resistance’ is also quite well done.
Two things downgraded the book from a recommended to a reasonable. The first is the underlying ‘science’ part of the Science Fiction label. It’s complete nonsense. As Evolution doesn’t have a direction or a purpose it can’t change direction or go into ‘reverse’. That’s not how it works. So, less Science Fiction more Fantasy in that regard. The only other issue I had with the narrative was the ending which essentially fizzled out over the last 4-5 pages. I was less than impressed by that. I don’t need everything to be wrapped up into a nice, neat bow, but I do need something. Overall, this was more than saved by the quality of the writing which I enjoyed a great deal. The author has penned a great deal more – though not SF – around her own Native American heritage and history and I’ll keep my eyes open for them should I come across them in my travels. As stated before, reasonable.
11 comments:
Hi CyberKitten!! I'm new to your blog and a new subscriber. I found your blog through Marianne's blog, Let's Read.
I really enjoyed your review of Louise Erdrich's novel. I have been familiar with many of Erdrich's book titles over the past decade or longer, but finally read and reviewed two of her novels late last year. I really enjoyed both, The Sentence and The Night Watchman. I'd recommend both if you haven't read either one of them.
Happy reading to you!!
Thanks! I'll check them out. Welcome to my little slice of the Interweb. I post most days and usually twice a day when I do so. My book reviews are (usually) on Monday & Thursday. My reading is all over the place so I'm sure you'll find something interesting to check out. I've also added your Blog to my List.
Thank you for the information. Sounds like you post more frequently than I do! I like that you read diversely as I do too. I don't stick to one genre. Although, I admit that I do have my favorite authors and genres.
I have what I call a 'butterfly mind'. I do hop from topic to topic and don't stay one one subject for very long. For example, I'm presently reading a book about the last 100 days of WW1, then it'll be a short classic, followed by a book on the evolution of upright walking in humans....
I suppose I'm the same as you with my reading. There are so many choices out there to read that I tend to pick and read what interests me in the moment. So, I'm a mood reader, if you will. I've tried to make reading lists of books I plan to read quarterly, but I tend to go off script and read only some of the books on that list while choosing other books I had not intended to read that quarter.
I do have an element of mood reading, but I do *try* to be a bit organised - at least I *try* to be! I have two long(ish) sets of books that I want to start soon(ish), or at least one of them. We'll see... [grin] I'm trying several things to stop me reading the top book off a pile and getting to some of the older stuff before they turn to coal under the pressure of the books stacked above them.
I like that you said the writing was good, but like you, the story has to end respectably at least. Have you read any books by Rebecca Roanhorse? She’s a Native American writer and I’ve really enjoyed her books. Right now I’m reading _Parable of the Sower_ by Octavia Butler because it was highly recommended. It’s just okay and I’m halfway through. It’s slow, not all the characters are as well developed as I would like. I will keep reading in hopes it will give me some idea why so many people like the book.
Books are complicated, so you can have a well written OK book or a good idea poorly presented. Like movies, you can have an essentially bad movie with a stand-out character... But I do find it best when all (or at least most) of the elements come together! It certainly didn't put me off reading more by her. I'm presuming that SF just isn't her 'thing'.
Not sure if I've heard of Rebecca Roanhorse, but I'll look out for her. I read one or two by Octavia Butler *ages* ago and remember enjoying it/them.
I stayed up until 11 last night reading. The action in Parable begins at the halfway mark in the book. It annoys me when it takes that long to get interesting, but at least it’s finally there!
I would've DNF'd it LONG before that point!
I’m notoriously patient/determined/stubborn, not sure those are always good qualities. 🤣
Post a Comment