About Me

My photo
I have a burning need to know stuff and I love asking awkward questions.

Thursday, May 15, 2008

Just Finished Reading: Where Eagles Dare by Alistair Maclean

On the eve of the invasion of Europe disaster strikes. General Carnaby, one of the central planners for the second front, is shot down over occupied Europe and captured by German forces. He is taken to the Sloss Adler – the Caste of Eagles – deep in the Alps. In a desperate attempt to rescue him a hastily thrown together team of British and American secret agents is dispatched with orders to succeed or die trying. The very outcome of the war is at stake. Or is it? It quickly becomes clear that little is what it first appears to be and that the leader of the rescue team has a very different agenda.

As this is one of my all time favourite films I was both interested in and apprehensive about reading the source material. The film is actually very close to the book and often lifts dialogue wholesale. Likewise the plot and timeline are almost identical including the very strange addition of an anachronistic helicopter. This both made it somewhat interesting but also fairly boring – having basically removed any possible surprise or suspense. It also turned out that the differences that did exist in the original novel where, on the whole, improved upon in the movie with the possible exception of a hidden ‘cat-fight’ between two very attractive women. But I digress…..

Taken on its own merits this is a pretty fair thriller with some nice twists and turns. In conjunction to the film it provides a quite interesting look at the original intentions of the author but offers little else. All in all though this was a reasonably entertaining read.

8 comments:

mark's tails said...

Nice, love Tom Toles, used to work for the Buffalo News before going big time at the Washington Post.

CyberKitten said...

That confused me for a moment - until I realised it was meant for the *previous* post... [laughs]

wstachour said...

I love the movie, though it does have a bit of '70s camp now. But still, WWII, espionage, unctuous Nazis, cable cars. How cool is that? I might have to read the book!

mark's tails said...

CK, my bad, I clicked on the wrong comment button. sorry.

Unknown said...

Why does everyone say "anachronistic Helicopter"?
The Germans flew helicopters in combat in WW2 and since 1936 they had numerous types.
Please don't criticise authors just because your own education is lacking.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6SrUyNG4fYA

CyberKitten said...

marthur said: The Germans flew helicopters in combat in WW2 and since 1936 they had numerous types.
Please don't criticise authors just because your own education is lacking.

The most advanced helicopter of the time was indeed German - the FL 282 Kolibri - a derivative of the Kriegsmarine experimental model (shown in the YouTube video) the Flettner FL 265. Only 20 prototypes were in service in 1943 & only a total of 32 pre-production aircraft were ever delivered to the German Navy.

It is conceivable (just) that this was the helicopter in the book - though obviously not the film - but I think it is highly unlikely on several grounds. Also, as the model was still highly experimental, I would have expected more surprise from those who saw it presumably for the first time.

wstachour said...

Ha! Who gets their undies in a bundle and takes the trouble to make a snide comment like that on this kind of subject matter?!

The internet brings 'em out.

dbackdad said...

"Ha! Who gets their undies in a bundle and takes the trouble to make a snide comment like that on this kind of subject matter?!" -- no doubt. That is one of the most unusual items that I've seen a blog commenter have their feelings hurt about. As Ebay showed us many years ago, there are collectors of just about anything somewhere in the world. And as you say, the internet in general has shown us that there are fringe collectors of obscure information. Marthur must be president of the early 20th Century helicopter club. Sheesh.