About Me

My photo
I have a burning need to know stuff and I love asking awkward questions.

Thursday, July 13, 2023


Just Finished Reading: 1916 – Ireland's Revolutionary Tradition by Kieran Allen (FP: 2016) [196pp] 

This was yet another one of those books that turned out not to be exactly what I’d expected. Indeed, it was far more about its sub-title than its main title. Although the author did discuss the events of the Easter Rising in Dublin in 1916 (briefly) as well as the underlying reasons for both the event and its failure (briefly), the main thrust of this often deeply political work was what happened next and how those events echoed through the following century until the present. 

After the failure of the Uprising and the quite brutal British response (things never go well when you’re firing artillery down streets into enemy held buildings) Ireland secured partial independence from the British Empire followed by a short bloody Civil War and counter-revolution. Here I learnt exactly why southern Ireland became the poster child for religious conservatism on steroids. I never fully realised before just how much of a stranglehold the Catholic church had over just about every aspect of Irish life south of the border with Northern Ireland. Coupled with the political power they had access to 24-7 it’s hardly surprising that a clamp down on unions, socialist politics in general (the fear of *communism* was the foundation of much of this and, it seemed, communism was defined as anything that even smelt of social justice or freedom of thought), abortion, divorce, women in any position of power or influence, women in higher education, essentially women as anything other than baby factories (within wedlock naturally) chained to the kitchen sink. Oh, and no access to contraception of any kind, indeed no universal access to healthcare of any kind – unless you could pay through the nose for it, or travel to England which amounted to the same thing. This didn’t really begin to change until the 1970’s and only really got going in the 80’s and beyond.  

On top of this was, as we know, the situation in the North with the minority Catholic community in the separated 6 Counties living under the heel of the majority Protestant community. As you might expect it wasn’t long until fighting broke out as it had been bubbling under for some time. As you’d also expect the Catholics got the rough end of things which prompted both a backlash from organisations like the IRA and the involvement of the British military – AKA ‘The Troubles’.  

Looked at from a very Left-wing perspective - (I hesitate to go so far as to say Marxist, but Karl does come up quite a bit throughout the book) as much of the countries revolutionary tradition/history centres around the life and thought of James Connolly (who I definitely need to read up about!) who was a devoted Socialist/Syndicalist and was a big fan of the bearded one – this was an often fascinating, if at times deeply political look at Irish history post-1916. I think I had a fair, if general, knowledge of Irish history over the last 100 years but I learnt a LOT in less than 200 pages which is cool. Definitely of interest to anyone who wants to dive deeper into Irish political history, though if you’re a novice to this country’s past I’d start with something a bit lighter! More on ‘1916’ to come. 

[Labels Added: 1, Labels Total: 56]

10 comments:

Marianne said...

This sounds highly interesting. I read Say Nothing a while ago which takes place later but reports about the same subject. Must find this. Thanks.

CyberKitten said...

I have a particular interest in modern Irish history because my dad was from Wicklow in the South. His family immigrated to England in 1939 (dad was age 10).

I have a few more books on 1916 to come and will, no doubt, pick up more about Irish history in general. Check out my 'Ireland' label over on the right for more!

'The Troubles' have a LONG back story (as does most history of course!) and it was interesting getting a different perspective on things. Hopefully I can follow this up with more reading.

Stephen said...

I imagine having an uprising in the middle of a war when Britain was already mobilized helped make the brutal response more possible. In a peacetime scenario there wouldn't have been as easy access to men in arms, artillery, etc.

CyberKitten said...

Yes, I understand that the British saw it as high treason rather than simple rebellion - apart from the fact that there was talk (and an actual request) for arms from Germany to facilitate things!! So, rather understandably especially at the time, the Brits too it VERY personally. So.... tanks and artillery on the streets and even (I think) calls for poison gas being used (by Churchill inevitably!).

Sarah @ All The Book Blog Names Are Taken said...

It will probably not surprise you at all that I am 100% in favor of reuniting Ireland into one country. I don't know that it will ever happen, but I hope so.

1916 is so fascinating to me. When Mom and I were in Ireland in 2010 we did the 1916 Walking Tour with Lorcan Collins. Going to Kilmainham Gaol was fantastic too.

In general I have read some great books about The Troubles. I just finished There Will Be Fire: Margaret Thatcher, the IRA, and Two Minutes That Changed History by Rory Carroll. Lorcan Collins also has some great books, and also wrote one of several books in a series about the leaders of the Easter Rising. The series is called 16 Lives.

Marianne said...

It is also a topic that interests me very much. Most of my life, we have feared war and had one going on right at our doorsteps. As you know, my son did an exchange semester in Belfast and we were lucky to be able to visit him. We did a lot of interesting visits to places that were connected to The Troubles (well, you can hardly find places in Belfast that were not), including a visit to the infamous Crumlin Road Gaol where we were guided by a former prisoner. When he heard that our son studied politics (well, European studies but he always said politics because that was a big part and easier to explain to strangers), we had a long talk with him. Totally interesting.

CyberKitten said...

That's VERY cool!

I remember watching The Troubles unfold on TV in the 70's. It got very real in the late 80's when I was working in London during one of the late bombing campaigns. I missed one bomb by 10-15 minutes and two railway platforms - my train went through that station just prior to the bomb going off - and I missed one more when I walked past a pub on my way to work around 3 hours before that bomb went off that lunchtime. Working in London made you VERY conscious of strange or out of place objects!!

The other weirdness was when the government brought in their mobile roadblocks. A few vans would show up, armed police would jump out - they had sub-machine guns and body armour - and they'd start pulling over suspicious cars. The first time I saw it everyone stood still and stared. We'd never seen police so heavily armed before! After a few weeks of that people stopped taking notice unless they were obviously shouting at YOU. How quickly we adapt to the bizarre!!

Marianne said...

Lucky you.

I remember when we went to Israel decades ago, there were always soldiers with arms on the street and in public transport. Nobody even looked at them, except when they were tourists like us.

This is such a sad story and the problem has not even been touched. I doubt we'll ever see an end of it. Though I said that about the German/German border and the Berlin wall.

CyberKitten said...

@ Marianne: One of the comforts of reading History is seeing that things in the past were different. Things change - sometimes slowly but sometimes very fast, often taking people by surprise although (looking backwards) all of the signs were already there. Sometimes things get worse (depending on your definition) but sometimes things get better too.

@ Sarah: I think Irish unification is inevitable seeing that Partition makes zero sense for a whole host of reasons. Its not going to happen tomorrow or in the very near future, but it is going to happen and then people will wonder exactly why it took so long!

16 Lives pops up on my Amazon recommendations from time to time. I'll check out 'There Will Be Fire'. Thanks for the pointer...

Marianne said...

So true, Kitten. The worst bit about reading History is that we don't seem to learn from it.