About Me

My photo
I have a burning need to know stuff and I love asking awkward questions.

Monday, June 17, 2024


Just Finished Reading: That Option No Longer Exists – Britain 1974-76 by John Medhurst (FP: 2014) [155pp] 

For those who lived through them, the 1970’s were memorably turbulent times in the UK. Not only were we in the midst of an IRA bombing campaign, but the ongoing oil crisis was helping to push inflation ever higher peaking at an AMAZING and quite eye-watering 26.87% in August of 1975. The year 1974 was also when we had a rare double election – both won by Harold Wilson’s Labour Party – the first such event since 1910 and the last to date (so far). During this era Britain was also wracked by strikes and I vividly remember doing homework (I was in my early/mid-teens at the time) by candlelight because of rolling blackouts caused by power station failures due to lack of coal. Although I didn’t appreciate it at the time – being both young and uninformed/stupid - I think that my parents were quite worried about the whole thing.  

Despite Wilson’s government (something I SO need to read up about further) being at least technically Labour – and MUCH further to the Left than more modern Labour governments – the author does go to town a bit on their lack of Socialist ‘chops’ and the lost opportunities to turn the country leftwards for decades to come (remember that Thatcher came to power in 1979 – in part because I voted for her). I can kind of understand this having seen far too often how timid Labour governments are even after been given a mandate to govern by gaining a LARGE majority. [Sidebar: It’ll be interesting to see how the next Labour government actually govern IF their majority is as high as predicted following the election on 4th July]. But, with things as they were the UK economy was in the process of being well and truly flushed down the toilet and needed a quick injection of cash to tide it over the bad bit. Going cap in hand to the IMF got the predicted response: You can have the money on the understanding that you ditch all of this ridiculous Socialist crap and go FULL austerity. Having little to no wriggle room the Labour government acquiesced, and any idea of Socialist Britain died with it. Simply that option no longer existed. 

Interestingly, especially after watching the 1988 TV adaptation of the book and (much) later reading ‘A Very British Coup’ by Chris Mullin, it transpired that the conspiracy to overthrow a hard Left Labour government wasn’t as far-fetched as you might think. There were actual high-level discussions with senior Civil Servants, businesspeople and ex-military about possible intervention if the Labour government went “too far” and the country needed a ‘course correction’. OBVIOUSLY, I’ll be reading further about THAT little detail. This was an interesting look into a turbulent political period from a distinctly left-wing (or “radical hard Left” for my American readers [lol]) viewpoint. Recommended. 

8 comments:

Marian H said...

You voted for Thatcher? Now that sounds like a story... :) No pressure to share, of course, but I'm curious if your political views changed or if it was a choice of the "lesser of two weevils." I really don't know much about the 80s politics, UK or US, other than the popularity of Reagan and Thatcher.

CyberKitten said...

Yes, I voted for Maggie in '79 (the first time I ever voted) and in '83 too! I think it was a combination of everything that was happening, plus most of my family were mostly right of centre in their beliefs and I guess I picked up a bit of that. In '83 I went to University... [grin] & I guess I became more 'politically educated' or just more aware of what was happening. It didn't help that Thatcherism was essentially destroying the country. I never voted Conservative after that. I was never what you might call a 'floating' or 'undecided' voter, but I have voted Independent, Green, Liberal, Liberal Democrat & Labour over the years. Mostly its Labour and I'm *more* than happy being labelled as a Socialist - although I've been called 'worse'. I'm probably more towards the Anarcho-Socialist side of things which is probably why Stephen & I get on and also argue so much about Politics. [lol]

Oh, I noticed the 'Master & Commander' reference... [grin]

Stephen said...

Thatcher is an interesting figure in that some British youtubers I watch HATE her -- despite the fact that they're gen Z. (Looking at you, Plumbella...) Say what you will about the Iron Lady, she had an impact. Dominic Sandbourne, the fellow who has a podcast with Tom Holland, has written several books on postwar Britain. I've got access to one that covers this area a bit.

CyberKitten said...

Oh, a LOT of people from my generation hate Maggie with a **passion**! I think about the best thing you can say about her was that she made a lot of people far more politically aware than they had been before. 'Impact' is the word, although I can think of quite a few less polite words to describe her wrecking ball policies.

I have several of Dominic Sandbrook's books about that era including:

State of Emergency - The Way We Were: Britain 1970-1974 and
Seasons in the Sun - The Battle for Britain 1974-1979

Also I have

When the Lights Went Out - What Really Happened to Britain in the Seventies by Andy Beckett

If you're interested in the period I reviewed Crisis? What Crisis? – Britain in the 1970’s by Alwyn W Turner here:

https://cyberkittenspot.blogspot.com/2010/01/just-finished-reading-crisis-what.html

Stephen said...

Honestly, I was just looking at it for the author. Sandbrook hosts that podcast "The Rest is History" that I like so much.

CyberKitten said...

Dominic Sandbrook did some good TV series about British history & Sci-Fi if you can watch them anywhere. They're all BBC productions.

Marian H said...

Wow, thanks for sharing! That's interesting, and I can relate. My first voting experiences were aligned with my parents', even when I was in uni. Then a mix of events and personal experiences put theories into concrete reality, and that opened my eyes to some things. That was around 2019-2021... I'm somewhat left of center now.

CyberKitten said...

I think that most kids growing up inevitably take on at least some of the beliefs of the parents - or go full 180 depending! Leaving home & going out into the world is going to impact on those beliefs though - again inevitably. Plus people change over time, most especially when you come into contact with people who hold different - and sometimes radically different - views on things.

Every year I move more to the Left although some people have thought I was an out and out leftie LONG ago. One of my early University tutors (mid 1980's) used to call me 'Comrade' in our Seminars. I asked him why? He said, well you're a Communist aren't you? No, I said. They're far too Right-wing for me.... [lol] Being in my mid-20's I was far more an Anarchist trouble maker... [grin]