About Me

My photo
I have a burning need to know stuff and I love asking awkward questions.

Monday, June 10, 2024


Just Finished Reading: L. A. Noir – The Struggle for the Soul of America’s Most Seductive City by John Buntin (FP: 2014) [343pp] 

Los Angeles was growing – FAST. On the back of it something else was growing too, just as fast if not faster – Crime. What wasn’t growing, much to the frustration of the Police Commissioner and much to the delight of certain elements, was the size of the Los Angeles Police Department. Compared to places like New York the ratio of police to citizen was starting to look pitiful. But what made it worse was the budget – something else not growing nearly as fast as required. Not only was the LAPD understaffed it was underpaid with new officers earning less than refuse collectors. It came as no surprise that a significant number of the LAPD was ‘on the take’ and not just the guys on the street. Something needed to be done and someone with the power and the balls to do it needed appointing to the role. That man was William H Parker. Seen by some as a self-obsessed bully and by others as the city’s saviour he was determined to root out corruption and clamp down on the growing crime epidemic sweeping the city. Opposing him was the city’s underground, Organised Crime and the politicians in City Hall. The fight for the soul of the City of Angels was about to begin. 

Like most everyone else, I’ve grown up with images of LA from movies and cop shows (some of which are mentioned in this often-fascinating book) but knew little if anything about the reality of the situation. No more! Unsurprisingly, quite a few of what I’d picked up from Noir cinema and shows like Dragnet actually had a reasonably firm basis in reality – most especially when they focused on corruption, police violence and racism and, probably most importantly, political interference. I know it shouldn’t have confused me as much as it did, but I found myself constantly shaking my head over the poor funding the police department received – no matter the real or perceived demands – as well as the demands from the commercial sector that ‘too much policing’ was ‘bad for business’, by which they normally meant gambling of course. With the in-roads made by Organised Crime the amount of money sloshing around – especially in City Hall – was astounding and, no doubt, contributed to the Police Departments underfunding and the slow-walking of modernisation efforts. Again, it was surprising just how long proper training – in Police College rather than ‘on the job’ - took to bed in properly as well as obvious improvements such as radios in patrol cars.  

Although not exactly an ‘eye-opener’ this was an interesting and often fascinating look at the inside of the LAPD in its formative years from the 1930’s and into the early 1990’s. I was certainly much more aware of some of the later events talked about here, but I still recognised a scattering of names from the 1940’s and 50’s too. Apparently made into the TV Series ‘Mob City’ (which I don’t think I’ve ever heard of) this is a recommended read for anyone interested in US Organised Crime or the City of Angels herself. More to come on both subjects.        

10 comments:

Stephen said...

Rockstar did an interesting and enjoyable game based on 1940s Hollywood called "LA Noire". Bit of a detective game in which the player has to find clues and interrogate suspects, using facial language and logic to figure out if people are lying. Some of its cases were based on real ones I read about in "American Detective":

https://readingfreely.com/2019/06/22/american-detective/

CyberKitten said...

I have a deep love for the Noir feel (as you may have noticed). It just *works* on SO many levels. Its a delight.

Stephen said...

Recently watched "The Thin Man" movie from 1934. I don't think I've read the book, though I Have read Hammett before. Oddly funny for a murder mystery.

CyberKitten said...

'Thin Man' is a brilliant movie. LOVE that pair. Such fun to watch on screen...

Sarah @ All The Book Blog Names Are Taken said...

Love love love this kind of stuff. I have a few books about LA as well. I love city biographies in general and also when they get specific about aspects within that city. You are SO lucky this is already on my TBR lol

CyberKitten said...

I thought you might like it [grin] I have a few similar ones about New York - especially about the blackout in the 70's. Interesting times!!

Sarah @ All The Book Blog Names Are Taken said...

You know me so well :) I have some great NY ones also. We probably have a lot of the same ones. I don't think I have any on the black out though, so I can't wait to see what you have!

CyberKitten said...

'Blackout' by James Goodman

'Ladies and Gentlemen, The Bronx is Burning - 1977, Baseball, Politics, and the Battle for the Soul of a City' by Jonathan Mahler

Sarah @ All The Book Blog Names Are Taken said...

I've the read The Bronx is Burning and it was kind of iffy for me, but hopefully you like it better. The Goodman book looks great, but my library doesn't have it.

CyberKitten said...

Not sure when I'll be reading them (as always) but I'll be reading them together as a mini deep dive - at some point!